I have to take a deep breath here because my enthusiasm for Rotters by Daniel Kraus is such that my review might quickly decompose to incoherent gushing.
This is the highest praise I can give:
If two of my favorite books got together and made a child, Stiff by Mary Roach and The Monstrumologist by Rick Yancey, Rotters would be that unholy Frankenstein child - a breathlessly macabre creation of horror and pathos.
Grave robbing. What kind of monster would do such a thing? It’s true that Leonardo da Vinci did it, Shakespeare wrote about it, and the resurrection men of nineteenth-century Scotland practically made it an art. But none of this matters to Joey Crouch, a sixteen-year-old straight-A student living in Chicago with his single mom. For the most part, Joey’s life is about playing the trumpet and avoiding the daily humiliations of high school.
Everything changes when Joey’s mother dies in a tragic accident and he is sent to rural Iowa to live with the father he has never known, a strange, solitary man with unimaginable secrets. At first, Joey’s father wants nothing to do with him, but once father and son come to terms with each other, Joey’s life takes a turn both macabre and exhilarating.
Death is all over this book, fear of death, physical death, emotional death, death of hope. Joey has been sheltered all his 16 years by his beloved mother, but when she dies and he goes to live with a father he's never met - Joey is pitched into a bleak and ugly new existence - and that's BEFORE he meets his first corpse.
As the son of the creepy and stinky "Garbage Man" (as Joey's father is called by the townspeople) Joey quickly becomes his new school's pariah. He is beaten almost daily, terrorized by a sadistic teacher, and has no friends. High school is a horrifying place and his cold father and dreary home are no comfort.
With ordinary society so putrid in its treatment of Joey, is it any wonder then that he becomes drawn to the mysterious world of grave robbing - his father's secret occupation? Joey buries himself in learning all about the underground realm of grave thievery composed of strange, solitary men loosely held together by pacts and old-fashioned codes of honor. Here, grave robbing is a calling and an art, almost noble in its tradition going back to the Resurrectionists of the 18th Century. Almost noble, but not quite - for nightly, Joey descends the underworld of foul, rotting corpses, Rat Kings, maggots, severed limbs in pursuit of jewelry and precious mementos to pawn. In sharing his father's shameful secret, a rough and unusual father-son bond develops between the two and Joey becomes his willing apprentice.
"The taking from graves, he said, is the oldest profession there is. Early man took what he needed from the mounds of his fallen fellows. Egyptian masks and sarcophagi, Chinese jade burial suits, all were useless to the soil and therefore recycled back into the world. Da Vinci stole bodies from the morgue to study anatomy, he told me. Michelangelo, too, though he didn't have the stomach for the necessary dissection. My stomach lurched--two feet more and the unwilling stomach would be my own.
"...After a brief period of rest, said my father, Michelangelo resumed his studies, and this is the mark of a true artist, to have the mettle to see what truly lies inside of a man. I inched forward so as to not miss a word. He was a better teacher than any at Bloughton High, better than any I ever had. The mess of his life---maybe it was only a mess when seen from a limited perspective. The possibility suddenly existed to me that there was other knowledge of such importance that it overwhelmed the world's quotidian concerns, and such knowledge came from the inside: bodies, bones and tissues, and maybe even another layer deeper, souls."
Of course Joey pays for entry into this morbid world of the Diggers when he turns his back on the living, whom he calls the Rotters. He digs himself into a black abyss of pain so deep that I was genuinely uncertain if he would ever climb out of it.
Rotters must have flaws, but I cannot think of any. I've been yearning for a truly dark YA book and now I've found one who's got dark in spades and then some: the corpses, the father-son relationship, the fascinating history of grave-robbing, the characters, the brilliant but mad villain, and sharp writing .
Your nose will wrinkle in disgust, you will shudder, you will want to turn away, but you won't because as twisted as Rotters is, you will be too thrilled to stop turning the pages.
Release date: April 5, 2011
Thank you very much to the Amazon Vine program for providing a copy for me to review!






Wow! This sounds different from any other new YA releases. Dead people, grave-robbers and a creepy story - what's not to love! Thank you for the review, otherwise I would have never heard of this book.
ReplyDeleteUsually I'd probably pass on this book just by the description, but because of your enthusiasm alone, I want to read it right this instant!!!!
ReplyDeleteGreat review lady!
Gush away! I'm sure you know as book lovers, we understand the feeling all too well. And don't kill me, but I haven't read any Kraus... yet. I was with you on this one until I got to the part about the maggots. LOL
ReplyDeleteStill, the grave robbing history sounds very interesting. You don't think of stuff like that, that it must have some type of history that people in that profession take pride in.
Poor Joey, his life and his pain sound like too much.
Stephanie,
ReplyDeleteI wrote ROTTERS and just happened to come upon this. You're the first to mention STIFF, which was one of my most important research texts. Congratulations! I'm happy you liked the book.
Best wishes,
Daniel
www.danielkraus.com
You know I've been on a YA ban for a while now for the main reason I have found them all to be the same. This one may be the inspiration I need to get back in the game. Sounds like a great book and one that I would enjoy more than most. Thanks for the review and the heads up. I'll know what to be on the look for next time I go to the store.
ReplyDeleteMisha - I just heard about this book last week, actually and it thought it sounded so cool - why hadn't I known about it before? I'm glad I could spread the word.
ReplyDeleteBookish Brunette - I know, it's not the most mainstream YA book, but that's part of its appeal. Thank you!
Daniel - Wow, thank you so much for commenting. I'm having an off-the-wall daydream of the kind of research that went into writing Rotters ... it must have been fun!
I wish Rotters a long and robust life- congratulations to you!
Ryan - I do believe Rotters will resuscitate the YA genre for you.
Missie - The story does go into scary emotional terrain but if you're in the mood for it, Rotters is very much worth a try.
ReplyDeleteI don't think this is for me. You know I hate a dark YA.
ReplyDeleteYea right...
Fine. Twist my arms. I am putting this on my wishlist! :D
"You know I hate a dark YA." Just a few hours early of April Fools, Melissa!
ReplyDeleteYikes! Somehow you made death and grave robbing seem appealing. Great review :)
ReplyDelete"If two of my favorite books got together and made a child, Stiff by Mary Roach and The Monstrumologist by Rick Yancey, Rotters would be that unholy Frankenstein child - a breathlessly macabre creation of horror and pathos."
ReplyDeleteOkay, that's just one of the greatest paragraphs I've ever read in a blog review!
Stacy - This book reinforced my decision to be cremated :)
ReplyDeleteLisa - Wow, thanks!
My father used to manage a funeral home, and the stories he would tell...there is some truly creepy stuff that goes on there. Though thankfully I've never heard of any grave robbing stories.
ReplyDeleteA book about corpses and grave robbing would normally not interest me at all but your enthusiasm has piqued my curiosity. Perhaps I'll give it a try. And if I like it maybe I'll pass it on to my father.
Simcha - Oh, I'm sure your dad could write a book about his experiences at the funeral home! I can only imagine...
ReplyDeleteOh my. Grave robbers! Oh sounds like you really enjoyed this one. So glad! :) Thank you!
ReplyDeleteThis sounds intriguing but I'm not sure I could handle it.
ReplyDelete